Wednesday, January 10, 2007

Interview with Dr. Ari Jaaki: The Podcast and Notes


Here's the link to the voice recording of the interview. I tried transcribing it but had some difficulty as we were talking at the same time at points and he showed some things that you could not see. However, a LOT of ground was covered.

I say "um" and "uh" too much.

Some notes and answers to what others have asked in comments in my last post:
  1. The 770 was no more or less successful as expected. (I got no actual figures) but it was so successful that it proved the market for such a device and they are very happy.
  2. This was the first time that Nokia had a software model that could upgrade capabilities through software upgrades (i.e. the IT2005 to IT2006.)
  3. Linux, Gnome, gstreamer, and other open-source choices were a BIG contribution to the success of this device.
  4. They didn't know offhand if SDHC would work. I took the N800 directly to the SanDisk booth and borrowed a card and it did not work. The SanDisk folks were VERY nice about this.
  5. We do not expect to see more Linux in other devices at this time because Series 40 and Series 60 work just great in phones.
  6. The primary function of the Internet Tablet series will be "Internet" and will continue to incorporate desktop Linux technologies.
  7. There were many lessons learned from the 770 that went directly into the 800, including supporting the latest formats, providing software upgrades, and more.
  8. The Nokia 770 is NOT end-of-life. It will still be sold and supported.
  9. The IT2007 will not be ported to the 770. The new hardware and software were built to go together.
  10. There's good discussion at about halfway into the interview about the division between laptops and the tablet, specifically use scenarios. Writing your novel, balancing your budget, etc. is best on a laptop. PIM functions and calls are best on phones. Internet (chat and browsing) is best on the Internet tablet.
  11. The dream features of the development team (Skype and Navigation) are in development and on the way soon. They hope to support more media formats in the future as well.
  12. I asked what Slashdot users always ask: Why does it has no phone or keyboard? Answer:
    1. Phones: Nokia has plenty of phones. Exact words: "If we were anyone but Nokia, not so many people will be asking this question." Very good point that I hadn't considered before. (More in the audio)
    2. Keyboard: The on-screen keyboard is functional. Bluetooth keyboards are an option. Keeping a hardware keyboard out keeps cost down, durability higher, and gives the option for people who want it. (Incidentally, the Control Panel "hardware keyboard" applet will directly pair with a bluetooth keyboard without any additional software.
  13. Incorporation of propriatary software (as opposed to all open-source) like Skype, Rhapsody, and third-party navigation software is an expansion of the portfolio and not an abandonment of open source. These are a value-add option.
All of the above was PARAPHRASING from the audio except that one direct quote above. If Dr. Jaaksi offers any corrections, I will post them.

I intend to stop by the Pavillion tomorrow to follow up on a couple questions and tell them what I found out about SDHC. According to Sandisk, SDHC is more a firmware option than a hardware option. The cards have identical pinouts. It may be possible for Nokia to code an SDHC driver. This remains to be seen.

There are far too many improvements in the N800 to write about in this post. Put specific questions in the comments so I can address them individually. Off I go again!

19 comments:

Anonymous said...

Too bad Jaaksi didn't say what exactly developer and consumer suport means. He said that effort will be put to N800. To me it sounded like no new operation system updates will be made for 770. It still feels like they don't care previous platform after they have new device on market.

Chippy said...

Nice podcast. Thanks

I have one burning question. Will they code skype to support video?

Steve.

Philip Langdale said...

SDHC support requires an additional patch of mine that is now in the MMC dev tree and which should hopefully be in mainline for 2.6.21

ossi1967 said...

I'm impressed. This is exactly the kind of infomation a consumer wants. There's so many articles about the N800 these days, but they all fail to answer the really important (well, not important, but nonetheless very interesting) questions. Thank you for making the most out of your opportunity.

Michael said...

The keyboard thing still bothers me. A BT keyboard is really not comparable to a solid one that would cover the screen. And the things mentioned, writing a novel etc. could also be done with the tablet given proper input devices. Why tell people to buy a large expensive laptop when you _could_ do everything with the tablet, assuming it had a good keyboard.

Also, even without the keyboard, they could have given it more buttons on both sides of the screen just to make it a bit easier to use.

Michael said...

Oh, and one more thing. Imagine a maemo platform spread out with a large screen as a laptop on a large area.

So a Razr thin laptop would be pretty sexy.

Peter said...

SDHC should be available with a updated kernel. Details here http://lkml.org/lkml/2007/1/1/35 blog post here http://intr.overt.org/blog/?p=41

Hanno said...

Michael, I disagree about the keyboard. I bought a bluetooth keyboard specifically for my Nokia 770 and expected it to be very useful.

Turns out that I hardly ever use it, at all.

Brian said...

Has anyone attempted a Bluetooth connection with a Treo 700w using PDANet's DUN capability? I'd love to be able to use one of these in the car in conjunction with my Treo 700w, but I know the "hacked" DUN with PDANet can be tad flakey at times...

christianhauck said...

just a wish about the podcast: would be nice and somewhat helpful if you mentioned the duration in minutes in the description on http://www.ourmedia.org/node/284512 . For the rest: thanks for keeping us updated.

Ove Nordström said...

Hi,
I would like to see a Nokia internet tablet, with a 11-inch screen & with a keyboard and also with Java support.

Nokia have now released Nokia N800 Internet Tablet, but it has a small screen, no keyboard and NO Java support.

Read more at my blog: I am waiting and waiting for cool Java devices

Roger said...

Great info. Thanks for summarizing this for us.

Roger

PS: Reminds me way back of learning to do interviews in journalism school. You learn really quickly to just nod your head a lot to encourage the person you're interviewing to keep going so you don't obliterate anything they're saying.

jpj said...

Re the Bluetooth DUN question: No Treo here, but N800 paired with a RAZR V3m on Verizon EV-DO, speakeasy.com's speedtest gives me 617 kbps down, 82 kbps up. Comparable to el cheapo DSL.

convulted said...

Does anyone else think that the omission of the screen cover on Nokia's part introduced a physical vulnerability into the tablet?
Personally I find it one of the biggest disadvantages of the N800 over the 770.

Bob said...

hi,

i don't know were exactly, bat already saw a posting that a 4GB sd card worked together with screenshot.

are these sdhc?

gan-chan said...

jpj:

You might be running into a Bluetooth limitation there, more than anything else - IIRC Bluetooth data transfer is limited to 723 kbps max (real-world obviously would top out at less).

convoluted:

Yeah, that was an unpleasant surprise for me too. Maybe they're hoping to stimulate the third-party accessory market? (Only half-joking there.)

Anonymous said...

Just a general question, but does meebo.com work on the N800?

Anonymous said...

Is it possible to use a bluetooth keyboard and a bluetooth phone (as modem) at the same time with the Nokia N800? (To e.g chat online with a full keyboard, where no wifi is available)

Anonymous said...

Incidentally, the Control Panel "hardware keyboard" applet will directly pair with a bluetooth keyboard without any additional software.

Thanks! That's exactly what I wanted to know. Amazing how many reviews/posts I've read that didn't mention that.